The Original Grantees of Campton, New Hampshire

Part Two - Col. Joseph Spencer and Dr. Joseph Spencer

To start I’d like to give a shoutout to my daughter-in-law. She taught herself how to crochet and she makes some fun stuff and some very artistic stuff. She’ll be getting more of her inventory listed later, but currently, you can buy penguins at her Etsy store. Mine lives in my dollhouse. Sushi anyone?

Now for the story…

Joseph Spencer Jr. was baptized on 22 July 1750 in the East Haddam, Middlesex, Connecticut Second Congregational Church.¹ That would have made him about sixteen years old when he arrived in Campton, Grafton, New Hampshire as one of the original grantees of the town.²

The river bed has changed over the past 250+ years and the river on the platt map from the Campton Historical Society did not line up perfectly with the Google Map.

While his father, Col. Joseph Spencer had bought land and invested in Campton businesses, Col. Spencer was active in Connecticut politics and probably did not spend a lot of time in Campton.³ When hostilities broke out with the British, Joseph Jr. reportedly served as a surgeon and aide to his father.⁴

To become a doctor in 1700, Joseph Jr. would have paid to study medicine under the tutelage of an established doctor.⁵ This apprenticeship usually took about seven years, and as there wasn’t a doctor in Campton until 1802, it is likely Joseph Jr. studied under one of the doctors in nearby Plymouth or Thornton.⁶ 

Dr. Spencer married his cousin Deborah Selden about 1777 probably in Hadlyme, New London, Connecticut.⁷ They first settled in Lebanon, Connecticut, but the family moved to Hoosick, Albany, New York where Dr. Spencer was practicing medicine in 1786.⁸ Dr. Spencer’s brother-in-law and former apprentice, Dr. George Selden, had gone west (he followed the Ohio River which would have taken him to the Virginia, Ohio, Kentucky area where he was captured by the natives and ended up in New Orleans before being rescued) and, “returned after many experiences, with a glowing account of the opportunities open to young men.”⁹ This probably inspired Dr. Spencer along with Nehemiah Spencer, his half-brother, and Abner Lord, his wife’s brother-in-law, to buy land on the Virginia side of the Ohio, River in what is now West Virginia.¹⁰ The families appear to have moved to the area between 1794 and 1795.¹¹ George Selden and his bride joined them around 1795.¹²

Image from the Historical Sketch of Joseph Spencer Major-General of the Continental Troops, Member of the Council of Safety, Congressman, JUudge, Deputy, Deacon, and Farm compiled by Charles Barney Whittlesey

Col. Spencer died in 1789 leaving the sons of his first marriage “no more having given them as I Judge already their full portion out of my Estate unless I should have a surplus of Estate after my two other sons have had two hundred pounds each and my five daughters one hundred cash with what they have already had out of my Estate.”¹³

Nehemiah Spencer, Col. Spencer’s youngest child, was about seventeen years old when his father died.¹⁴ The court granted his older brother Jared guardianship.¹⁵ As guardian, Jared was not expected to take physical custody of his brother but to care for Nehemiah’s inheritance (worth about $50,000 in 2024), until he reached adulthood at twenty-one.¹⁶ And when he turned twenty-one, Nehemiah jumped feet-first into adulthood.

First, he married seventeen-year-old Betsey Swan on 14 February 1793 in Millington, East Haddam, Middlesex, Connecticut.¹⁷ Then he bought land in what is now West Virginia near “Middle Island River” about twenty-five miles north of his brother’s land and adjoining land Abner Lord had purchased.¹⁸

On 1 December 1795, the Virginia legislature approved the formation of the town of Vienna on land owned by Dr. Spencer and his brother-in-law, Abner Lord.¹⁹ Nehemiah Spencer and George Selden were two of the seven trustees who were ordered to divide the one hundred acres into half-acre lots and to lay out the streets.²⁰ They were also required to advertise the lots for public auction which traditionally took place at the front door of the courthouse.²¹ 

In 1795, Nehemiah paid the head tax for himself but didn’t own a horse.²² Dr. Spencer had six horses and Nehemiah, who was probably living nearby with his family instead of “near Middle Island River,” most likely borrowed one when he needed to travel to the Harrison County Courthouse in Clarksburg.²³ When the act to form the town was repealed in 1799 and a new one issued, the area for the town was reduced to sixty acres and Nehemiah was no longer a trustee.²⁴

Plow, c. 1938, watercolor and graphite on paper by John Thorsen. Image courtesy of the National Gallery of Art, Washington.

Dr. Spencer and Nehemiah probably didn’t learn farming from their father. East Haddam’s land was not good for farming, and while Col. Spencer, a career military leader and politician, kept an ox, cattle, sheep, pigs, and a couple of horses, his bent plow was probably not used for anything more than the kitchen garden.²⁵ Good farming land in East Haddam was expensive, and most residents raised cattle for the Boston market, fished, and built ships.²⁶

Dr. Spencer and his family would cross the Ohio River to visit Marietta, Washington, Ohio (about 10 miles away) for needs that could not be met in their Virginian western frontier farming community. One of those needs was spiritual. 

The Spencer and Selden families were members of the Congregational Church whose teachings were based on Puritan beliefs.²⁷ There were other New England transplants in the area and on 6 December 1796, the residents of Marietta, Belpre, Waterford, and Vienna organized a church for those who could prove they were members of the Congregational or Presbyterian faith (later Baptists were allowed to join).²⁸ Dr. Spencer was one of the first members and served as Deacon from 1799 until his death.²⁹ 

While Dr. Spencer remained in Vienna until his death on 11 May 1824, the other family members drifted away.³⁰ Abner Lord moved to Marietta where he operated a ship-building business and general store before running into financial difficulties and leaving the city.³¹ Nehemiah also went to Marietta before returning to Connecticut.³² George Selden moved to Millersburg, Bourbon, Kentucky.³³ Except for William Selden Spencer who died childless, Dr. Spencer’s adult children appear to have all left Vienna.³⁴

Dr. Joseph Spencer's death notice which appeared in the American Friend in Marietta, Ohio on 20 May 1824.

1. East Haddam Second Congregational Church and Ecclesiastical Society Known as Millington Church and Society Records, Vol. 1 (1745-1776), p. 7, baptism of Joseph Spencer, 22 July 1750; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CS3F-6S94-L : accessed 15 October 2024), image 12; Connecticut State Library, Hartford.

2. Rev. Isaac Willey, “The Early History of Campton,” in Proceedings at the Centennial Celebration of the Town of Campton, New Hampshire 12 September 1867 (Concord: A.G. Jones, 1868), 16; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/library/books/viewer/21905 : accessed 15 October 2024), image 23. Also, Campton Town Records Vol. 1, 1767-1826, 5, Names of the Grantees of Campton; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QSQ-G99K-WFGS : accessed 16 October 2024), image 4; New Hampshire Bureau of Vital Records and Statistics, Concord.

3. See Deborah Carl, “The Original Grantees of Campton, New Hampshire: Part One,” Kinship Projects, Case Studies, and Genealogy Tips (https://yourfamilyquest.substack.com/p/the-original-grantees-of-campton : accessed 16 October 2024). Also, Hosford B. Niles, The Old Chimney Stacks of East Haddam, Middlesex County, Connecticut (New York: Lowe & Co. 1887), 118-122.

4.  Wm. B. Trask, “Necrology,” The New England Historical & Genealogical Register XXI (January 1867): 195; imaged, GoogleBooks (https://books.google.com : accessed 16 October 2024). Also, Louis C. Duncan, Medical Men in the American Revolution 1775-1783 (Carlisle Barracks, Pennsylvania: Medical Field Service School, 1931), 409.

5. Paige Gibbons Backus, “‘Medicine has Scarcely Entered its Threshold’: Medicine in the 1700s,” 18 January 2022, American Battlefield Trust (https://www.battlefields.org/learn/articles/medicine-has-scarcely-entered-its-threshold-medicine-1700s : accessed 16 October 2024).

6. Willey, “The Early History of Campton,” in Proceedings at the Centennial Celebration of the Town of Campton, New Hampshire 12 September 1867, 26 & 37.

7. Sophie Selden Rogers, Elizabeth Selden Lane and Edwin van Deusen Selden, Selden Ancestry: A Family History Giving the Ancestors and Descendants of George Shattuck Selden and his wife Elizabeth Wright Clark (Oil City, Pennsylvania: Edwin van Deusen Selden 1931), 125; imaged, HathiTrust (https://babel.hathitrust.org : accessed 16 October 2024). George Shattuck Selden, Esq. (great nephew of Deborah Selden and father of the authors) in 1877 said Deborah Selden married Dr. Joseph Spencer on 4 September 1777. Corroborating evidence has not yet been found.

8. Col. Joseph Spencer lived in East Haddam, Hartford (later Middlesex), Connecticut so the Joseph Spencer of Lebanon, Windham (formerly New London), Connecticut, selling land in Campton, Grafton, New Hampshire was his son, Dr. Joseph Spencer. See Grafton County, New Hampshire, Records Deeds,  Vol. 17 (1793-1794), p. 212, Joseph Spencer of Lebanon, Windham, Connecticut sells Thomas Mumford of Groton, New London, Connecticut land in Campton, Grafton, New Hampshire on 7 December 1779; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSRH-ZQCW-8 : accessed 16 October 2024), image 607. Also, Albany County, New York, Deed Book, Vol. 11 (1785-1788), pp. 243–242, Samuel Guthrie of Hoosick, Albany, New York sells Joseph Spencer “of the District aforesaid, physician,” land in Hooksick on 5 August 1786; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-L9WC-6ZL9 : accessed 16 October 2024); images 164–165; Albany County Courthouse, Albany.

9.  Rogers, Lane and Selden, Selden Ancestry, 125 & 131–132.

10. Harrison County, West Virginia, Entry Book, Vol. 1 (1784-1799), p. 178, Austin Nicholls reported on 22 August 1793 that 3,000 acres were surveyed for Joseph Spencer by virtue of Treasury Warrents granted to Alexander Dick and others; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSG6-VSF3-H : accessed 17 October 2024), image 97; Harrison County Courthouse, Clarksburg, West Virginia. Also, Harrison County, West Virginia, Deed Book, Vol. 2 (1795-1797), p. 289, Abner Lord of Lyme, New London, Connecticut sells to Samuel P. Lord of East Haddam, Middlesex, Connecticut, land in Virginia on the “Waters of Middle Island River” bounded by land of Nehemiah Spencer on 26 July 1794; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CS4K-DH31 : accessed 17 October 2024), image 179; Harrison County Courthouse, Clarksburg, West Virginia.

11. Harrison County Personal Property Tax Book, 1795, 8 & 12, Abner Lord, Joseph Spencer, and Nehemiah Spencer are listed on the “Tythable & Taxable property” list for Joseph Davidson’s district; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSQK-PSSF-Z : accessed 17 October 2024), imaged 127 & 129; Virginia State Library, Richmond. Abner Lord, Joseph Spencer, and Nehemiah Spencer do not appear in the Harrison County Personal Property Tax Book for 1793 and 1794.

12. Sophie Selden Rogers, Elizabeth Selden Lane and Edwin van Deusen Selden, Selden Ancestry, 132–133. Also, Harrison County Personal Property Tax Book, 1796, 21, Joseph Spencer, Nehemiah Spencer, George Silding [probably George Selden] are listed on the “Tythable & Taxable property” list for Joseph Davidson’s district; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSQK-PSSF-3 : accessed 17 October 2024), image 150; Virginia State Library, Richmond. Also, Harrison County Personal Property Tax Book, 1797, 16, George Seldon, Joseph Spencer, and Nehemiah Spencer are listed on the “Tythable & Taxable property” list for Benjamin Bartlett’s district; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSQK-PSS6-5 : accessed 17 October 2024), image 168; Virginia State Library, Richmond.

13. Find A Grave, database with images (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/10028446/joseph-spencer/ : accessed 17 October 2024), Maj Gen Joseph Spencer (1714-1789), memorial created by Jan Franco with gravestone image by Jan Franco; citing Nathan Hale Park Cemetery, East Haddam, Middlesex, Connecticut. Also, Colchester, New London, Connecticut, Probate Records, Vol. 5 (1780-1790), p. 504, Will of Joseph Spencer of East Haddam, Middlesex, Connecticut, 30 January 1788; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-992N-24JZ : accessed 17 October 2024), image 276; Connecticut State Library, Hartford.

14. East Haddam Second Congregational Church and Ecclesiastical Society Known as Millington Church and Society Records, Vol. 2 (1733-1931), p. 15, baptism of Nehemiah Spencer, 24 May 1772; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CS3F-6S94-W : accessed 17 October 2024), image 48; Connecticut State Library, Hartford. Also, Colchester, New London, Connecticut, Probate Records, Vol. 5 (1780-1790), p. 503, Jared Spencer is assigned guardianship of his 14-year-old brother, Nehemiah Spencer, March 1789; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-992N-24JZ : accessed 17 October 2024), image 276; Connecticut State Library, Hartford.

15. Colchester, New London, Connecticut, Probate Records, Vol. 5 (1780-1790), p. 503, Jared Spencer is assigned guardianship of his 14-year-old brother, Nehemiah Spencer.

16. Robert W. Baird, “Orphans & Guardians,” Bob’s Genealogy Filing Cabinet: Southern and Colonial Genealogies (https://genfiles.com/articles/orphans-guardians : accessed 18 October 2024).

17. East Haddam Second Congregational Church and Ecclesiastical Society Known as Millington Church and Society Records, Vol. 2 (1733-1931), p. 122, Marriage of Nehemiah Spencer to Betsy Swan, 14 February 1793.

18.  Harrison County, West Virginia, Deed Book, Vol. 2 (1795-1797), p. 289, Abner Lord of Lyme, New London, Connecticut sells to Samuel P. Lord of East Haddam, Middlesex, Connecticut, land in Virginia on the “Waters of Middle Island River” bounded by land of Nehemiah Spencer on 26 July 1794. 

19. Samuel Shepherd,  “ACT to establish a town on the land of Joseph Spencer and Abner Lord, in the county of Harrison (passed 1 December 1795)” in Statues At Large of Virginia from October Session 1792 to December Session 1806, Inclusive,  (Richmond: Samuel Shepherd, 1833), Vol. 1, p. 428; imaged, HathiTrust (https://babel.hathitrust.org: accessed 18 October 2024), image 434.

20. Shepherd, “ACT to establish a town on the land of Joseph Spencer and Abner Lord, in the county of Harrison (passed December 1, 1795)” in Statues At Large of Virginia from October Session 1792 to December Session 1806, Inclusive, Vol. 1, p. 428. “Auction at the front door of the Court House” or words to that effect appear many times in the Harrison, West Virginia deed books and court orders. One example is found in the Harrison County, West Virginia, Book of Deeds, Vol. 61 (1877-1879), p. 138, Bankruptcy of Bennett Bussey where a public auction of his property was “duly advertised” and held on 30 May 1878 at the front door of the Court House; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-C37T-5XV8 : accessed 18 October 2024), image 446; Harrison County Courthouse, Clarksburg, West Virginia.

21.  Shepherd,  “ACT to establish a town on the land of Joseph Spencer and Abner Lord, in the county of Harrison (passed 1 December 1795)” in Statues At Large of Virginia from October Session 1792 to December Session 1806, Inclusive, Vol. 1, p. 428. 

22. Harrison County Personal Property Tax Book, 1795, 12, Joseph Spencer and Nehemiah Spencer are listed on the “Tythable & Taxable property” list for Joseph Davidson’s district.

23. Harrison County Personal Property Tax Book, 1795, 12, Joseph Spencer and Nehemiah Spencer are listed on the “Tythable & Taxable property” list for Joseph Davidson’s district.

24. Shepherd, “ACT to establish a town on the lands of Alexander Madill, and Joseph Spencer, Abner Lord, and Austin Nichols (passed January 21, 1799)” in Statues At Large of Virginia from October Session 1792 to December Session 1806, Inclusive, Vol. 2, p. 176; imaged Hathi Trust (https://babel.hathitrust.org : accessed 18 October 2024), image 182.

25.  David D. Field, A History of the Towns of Haddam and East Haddam (Middletown: Loomis and Richards 1814), 8; imaged, HathiTrust (https://babel.hathitrust.org : accessed 18 October 2024), image 16. Also, Colchester, New London, Connecticut, Probate Records, Vol. 5 (1780-1790), p. 506, Inventory of the real and personal belongs of Col. Joseph Spencer.

26. Field, A History of the Towns of Haddam and East Haddam, 8–10.

27. “The Congregational Christian Tradition,” Congregational Library & Archives (https://www.congregationallibrary.org/congregational-christian-tradition : accessed 18 October 2024).

28. C. E. Dickinson, A Century of Church Life: A History of the First Congregational Church of Marietta, Ohio 1769–1896 (Marietta: E. R. Alderman & Sons, 1896), 18–19. 

29. Dickinson, A Century of Church Life: A History of the First Congregational Church of Marietta, Ohio 1769–1896, 164 & 193. The book says Joseph Spencer died in 1825 and served as Deacon until 1825, but Joseph’s death notice appeared in the newspaper in 1824, so Dickinson must have the year wrong.

30. Dr. Joseph Spencer Obituary, American Friend (Marietta, Ohio), Thursday, 20 May 1824, p. 3, col. 3.

31. Perhaps a future #Tell Their Story.

32. Mary Ann Spencer Cash Obituary, Bradford Argus (Towanda PA), Thursday, 8 February 1883; clipping provided to Deborah A. Carl by Katie Replogle on 23 July 2024.

33. Bourbon County, Kentucky, Case Files, 15723–15816, Case 15737, Lewis Vermont the executor of John Lavory’s estate was pursuing a debt against the estate of George Selden and wanted to seize George’s house and lot in the town of Millersburgh, Bourbon, Kentucky and named George’s wife and children in the petition to collect the debt, filed 7 November 1826; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSY9-Q3WH-T : accessed 19 October 2024), images 335–337; Bourbon County Circuit Court, Paris, Kentucky.

34. Perhaps a future Kinship Project.